We’re confused by this pic of Sarah Michelle Gellar, Seth Green, and Macaulay Culkin

In the forever-fascinating world of celebrities, one of the latest photos posted by Buffy the Vampire Slayer star Sarah Michelle Gellar has us baffled. On her Instagram, the actress shared a throwback picture of herself, Seth Green, and Macaulay Culkin. It’s a delight to see, but there are just So. Many. Questions.

Take a look at it and see if this doesn’t feel like a puzzle we all have to work through:

Plus, leave it to the beautiful Sarah Michelle Gellar to be mysterious about the whole thing and not give us any details about where exactly this was, when this happened, and you know, why.

Sarah wrote, “Ok @sethgreen I promise last one (for now) but I came across this and it reminded me of one of our best trips #tokyo.”

Alright, so we know this was taken in Tokyo. Were they filming the same movie? Were all three of them randomly there together? What did they buy? Also, does Sarah Michelle Gellar ever age?! She looks exactly the same in that picture as she does now!

Even though we don’t know all the details, we’re guessing that these three are most likely just hanging out in Tokyo, as famous friends do. After all, Sarah Michelle and Seth have been working together for years (they were even in a commercial together 17 years before Buffy came out!). As for Macaulay, Sarah Michelle attended high school with him. So maybe Sarah brought Seth and Macaulay together in Tokyo?

Questions aside – what we know for sure is that Sarah loves a good throwback picture. Because she’s been posting them left and right lately.

Sarah also shared a throwback picture of her wax figure and Seth Green, from over 10 YEARS ago:

Keep the pictures coming, Sarah! But maybe with some more info next time, because there are so many things we really need to know.