Natalia Lusinski
Updated Sep 04, 2016 @ 9:47 am
Credit: nathankress/Instagram

We can’t believe how grown up Nickelodeon’s iCarly cast looks in their reunion photo on Instagram. I mean, if they’re growing up, that means we are too, right?! (Gasp!)

Cast members Nathan Kress, Miranda Cosgrove, Jennette McCurdy, Noah Munck and Jerry Trainor came together Friday, September 2 for a surprise reunion.

Kress had posted the photo above, saying,

“The semi-bi-annual iCarly ‘Where Are We Now?’ conference was last night. Love these people 😊”

Aww. We love you all, too.

Then Cosgrove posted the same picture to her Insta account, too, with a heart emoji that perfect encapsulated exactly how we felt about the picture, too. She seems to think of her fellow iCarly cast a lot. Just a couple months ago, she posted this picture for McCurdy’s birthday.

We can’t believe the show stopped four years ago.

But, by the looks of it, at least on social media, it still seems the cast is as close as ever. And they’re growing up IRL, too.

But, the big question is: What is everyone doing now?!

Aside from official reunion dreams, Cosgrove’s been starring in the show Crowded, and will also be in Despicable Me 3. McCurdy signed a development deal with Canvas Media, Munck’s been focusing on producing electronic music as “NoxiK,” and Trainor has been acting in shows like Hunt the Truth and Still the King. Kress got married last November to London Elise Moore and, yes, some cast members were (of course) in attendance.

In the meantime, we’ll just have to keep going back and watching old eps of iCarly while we wait for the ~official~ reunion. Or maybe we’ll just have to start planning it ourselves…