Credit: Billie Lourd/Instagram

If we had to pick the two most *perfect* Halloween shows out there, obviously we’re going with American Horror Story and Scream Queens. Though neither one of them is actually rooted to the Halloween holiday, both have had killer (pun intended) Halloween episodes, along with a hefty dose of murder and mayhem literally all the time.

Over the weekend, there was the most epic AHS/Scream Queens get-together, and we are forever sad we weren’t invited too (let’s pretend our invitation just got lost in the mail). The group included, but was by no means limited to: Evan Peters, Emma Roberts, Billie Lourd, Abigail Breslin, John Stamos, Taylor Lautner, and Glenn Powell. And Josh Peck, because it was also a mini Grandfathered reunion, too.