Milo Ventimiglia’s career has been pretty diverse over the years — particularly in his TV shows Gilmore Girls, Heroes, and This Is Us. But get ready to see Jess Mariano like you’ve never seen him. That’s because Ventimiglia is in a new movie, Devil’s Gate, and in an interview with Bustle, he made it clear that not everyone is going to like him in this supernatural thriller.

The film, which premiered at the Tribeca Film Festival, stars Ventimiglia as Jackson Pritchard, a man whose wife and child have gone missing. The police see him as a suspect — and you just might not trust him either.

What’s a Jack Pearson fan to do!?

In an interview with Bustle about Devil’s Gate, Ventimiglia laughingly said that his fans “are not gonna like me in this one.” He further explained, saying:

In case you don’t believe Ventimiglia, take a look at this clip from Devil’s Gate that The Hollywood Reporter released exclusively. It also features his costars Amanda Schull and Shawn Ashmore.

As you can see, something is definitely shifty about Ventimiglia’s latest character and the Devil’s Gate director, Clay Staub, told Bustle, “Where [Ventimiglia] starts and where he finishes is a completely different place. You might say it’s a little bit different than anything or everything [he’s] done.”

So set all expectations aside before embarking on watching Ventimiglia in Devil’s Gate. And if you don’t like what you see — well, you can’t say that the beloved actor didn’t warn you.