Yvonne Craig as Batgirl
Credit: Len Trievnor/Express/Hulton Archive/Getty Images

Oh, snap. We can’t believe our eyeballs but somehow the list of actresses in the running to play Batgirl is floating around the web, and you better believe we’ve already looked it over and had an instant fangirl meltdown over the prospects.

Earlier this spring, Twitter sleuths thought they’d pegged Lindsay Morgan as Batgirl‘s lead actress, but according to Paste magazine, a list that cropped up on Reddit indicates otherwise.

As the mag reports, Reddit user DCEUThrowaway89 claims that Warner Brothers would like to announce its highly anticipated Batgirl star at this year’s Comic-Con, which takes place later this month.

Previously, the film’s director Joss Whedon suggested the actress he casts as Barbara Gordon would not be a big name star, but this list definitely features a few familiar faces.

Needless to say, we’re totally geeked. *Assuming this is true, but whatever, it’s fun to think about.

Elle Fanning

Olivia Cooke

Katherine Langford

Jane Levy

Margaret Qualley

Haley Lu Richardson

Emma Roberts

Naomi Scott

Bella Thorne

Credit: Paul Archuleta/FilmMagic

Obviously, all of these actresses have the chops have the chops to do the role justice, but the studio is allegedly eyeing Langford first, followed by Fanney, Levy and Qualley.

A little disappointed not to see any women of color, but like we said, this is only speculative information from Reddit.

Batgirl doesn’t hit theaters until 2019, which feels so incredibly far off. All of this speculation is a bit unnerving, so let’s hope Warner Brothers puts us out of our misery later this month with an official cast announcement.