Whether you love it or hate it (though let’s be real, everyone loves it), The Notebook is one of the most iconic romance movies of our time. Noah and Allie’s never-ending love for each other is transcendent, and the ending gets us every single time. But what if the movie ended differently? Apparently, for Netflix users in the U.K., it does. According to USA Today, the 2004 film is currently available for British users to stream, but fans have noticed a distinct difference during the finale.
In the version of The Notebook that most fans are probably familiar with (spoiler alert), the last scene entails an employee at Allie’s nursing home discovering that the couple had passed away together in their sleep. But, according to The Independent, the version on British Netflix ends with the pair holding hands while looking out at a lake, leaving what comes next open to interpretation. This is significant change and drastically changes the meaning of the ending (“Do you think our love could take us away together?”…”I think our love can do anything we want it to.”)
Obviously, Twitter took note.
However, it appears that Netflix isn’t behind the alternate ending. In a February 27th tweet, Netflix U.K. & Ireland wrote that “an alternate version of the movie exists and was supplied to us.” The streaming service also promised that it was “getting to the bottom of it asap.”
Some Twitter users even claimed that they had only ever seen the Netflix ending to the movie before, adding to the confusion.
It’s definitely plausible that there are two different cuts of The Notebook, but if that’s the case, not even Nicholas Sparks knew. The author, who wrote the 1996 novel that the movie is based on, said on Today that he found out about the Netflix ending “the same way everyone else [did].”
Whatever’s going on with the Netflix version of The Notebook, we hope the powers that be can figure it out—preferably before March 1st, when the epic romance is set to begin streaming in the U.S.. We want all of The Notebook, forever, every day.