Arielle Tschinkel
August 14, 2019 7:13 am

We were fully stoked last month when The Little Mermaid casting rumors were afire, basking in the speculation that Harry Styles would be playing Prince Eric opposite Halle Bailey as Ariel in the upcoming live-action remake. But it seems like we won’t get to see the former One Direction singer go under the sea, because Variety—along with other sites—has confirmed that Styles passed on the role. The silver lining? The fun speculation around Prince Eric’s casting is still on.

Sources told Variety that initial reports were “premature” and Styles made the decision to pass “amicably,” which is definitely a big bummer. But it seems that Disney is already on the hunt, and a decision is expected to be made soon.

It’s not just Prince Eric that everyone is buzzing about. It seems Melissa McCarthy is on deck to play the live-action Ursula, though there hasn’t been official confirmation. Jacob Tremblay is rumored to be playing Flounder, and Awkwafina could be a gender-bent Scuttle. Reportedly, Javier Bardem is in talks to play Ariel’s father, King Triton.

Social media users were understandably upset that Styles passed on The Little Mermaid, with plenty taking to Twitter to express their sadness over the news.

Still, as sad as we are, Twitter came through with some seriously solid suggestions as to who should play the dapper and charming human prince, so casting execs, take note.

Some users think Disney star Jordan Fisher should snag the role, and we are here for this.

Others think a gender-swapped Eric is in order, suggesting Zendaya and Tessa Thompson, and we love it.

One person is super into Timothée Chalamet as Prince Eric, and we could totally see this.

And look, we love you, Henry Cavill, and this looks like a pitch-perfect Eric, but we think the age difference is a concern.

Several people threw their favorite K-Pop singers into the ring, and they definitely have the vocal chops and charisma in spades.

Some think it should be Shawn Mendes, and we also love this suggestion.

These are all great casting choices, so here’s hoping that Disney has something magical up their sleeve. If you need help making the decision, give us a call, guys. We have more than a few excellent ideas. Stay tuned.