Photo of Taylor Swift at Bluebird Cafe in Nashville
Credit: John Shearer / Getty Images for 13 Management

Taylor Swift may be one of the top-selling female recording artists of all time, but that doesn’t mean she’s forgotten where she came from. The chart-topper surprised an intimate audience of about 40 (lucky!) music fans on Saturday, March 31st, when she returned to the same venue where she was first “discovered” back in 2005.

Prolific country songwriter Craig Wiseman was slated to headline the small show at Nashville’s famed Bluebird Cafe. But after he took the stage, Wiseman welcomed none other than Tay Tay herself to join him (to a standing ovation, of course). The two first met at a charity show back when Swift was just a teenager, according to The Tennesseean.

Besides performing staples like “Shake It Off” and “Love Story,” Taylor Swift knocked back a shot of Fireball Whisky and reminisced about her roots.

Oh, to be a fan in that crowd!

Wiseman hilariously recalled a CMT after-party at which he introduced Swift to the cinnamon whiskey she enjoyed again Saturday night.

Laughing along, Taylor Swift confessed that the shots weren’t the only thing to disappear at that party.

The singer, who recently dropped two music videos for “Delicate,” admitted that she and friend/fellow musician Ed Sheeran made off with a large inflatable bottle of Fireball. Because sure, why not?! false

Swift’s surprise performance was recorded for a documentary celebrating the 35th anniversary of the Bluebird Cafe, where Swift was offered her first publishing deal as an eighth-grader.

Obviously, this was one incredible surprise that will forever be part of the Bluebird Cafe’s musical history. Enjoy your success, T-Swift — you earned it.