As any good Kar-Jenner fan knows, Kylie Jenner kept her pregnancy with baby Stormi extremely under wraps. So under wraps, in fact, that the world didn’t even know she was pregnant until she released a video in early February—several days after she gave birth. At the time, Kylie explained that she wanted to keep the pregnancy experience to herself and do what felt best for her health and her baby. And while we totally respect that, in practice it also meant we’ve hardly ever seen a photo of Kylie actually pregnant. Which is kind of a bummer for us Kylie stans.

However, the makeup mogul just blessed us with several throwback videos from Halloween 2017 (when she would have been about six months along). She posted the “angelic” footage to her Insta Story, and we took the below screenshots for posterity.

Credit: Kylie Jenner / Instagram
Credit: Kylie Jenner / Instagram
Credit: Kylie Jenner / Instagram

Gorgeous, right? Kylie absolutely crushed the pregnancy Halloween costume game, and we’re bowing down retroactively.

Oh, and of course, Kylie crushed Halloween 2018, too.

She went as a Barbie, a storm cloud, a Victoria’s Secret angel, and a Fanta Girl.

Like we said: Crushed it.