American Vandal
Credit: Netflix /

American Vandal—Netflix’s most marathoned show—is back with a new gripping case. This time around, expert documentarians Peter Maldonado and Sam Ecklund have another Whodunnit investigation on their hands, and it involves…poop.

The first trailer for American Vandal Season 2 revolves around a Catholic school that’s being terrorized by “The Turd Burglar,” a prankster who slips laxatives into people’s food, causing mass chaos of the grossest kind.

Fresh off the heels of their phallus-related case, Peter and Sam searched high and low to find a new baffling incident to tackle. After trawling deep in referrals, they eventually found the deeply absurd St. Bernadine’s “mass defecation” case.

Tyler Alvarez and Griffin Gluck will reprise their roles as investigative reporters Peter and Sam, but the sophomore season also brings new faces: Men, Women, and Children’s Travis Tope, Sweet/Vicious’ Taylor Dearden, unReal’s Melvin Gregg, and Dear White People’s DeRon Horton will all be making appearances.

American Vandal Season 2 hits Netflix on September 14th. Warning: It’s not for the faint of heart.