Credit: Ilya S. Savenok / Getty

If there’s one thing we love about American Horror Storyoh who are we kidding, we love EVERYTHING about AHS – it’s the cast. And one of the reoccurring cast members we love most, OF COURSE, is Evan Peters.

Credit: FX /

As one of the few regular cast members who has appeared in every season (along with superstars Sarah Paulson and Lily Rabe), Evan seems to only gets better with every reinvented season of AHS – although, coooome oooon, Season 6!? And, of course, we’ve also fallen in love with his turn as Quicksilver X-Men: Days of Future Past and X-Men: Apocalypse.

Credit: 20th Century Fox /

But there was a time BELIEVE IT OR NOT when Evan wasn’t quite the ~serious~ thesp we all know him as now. A time when he was a bit more like…


Credit: SGranitz / Getty

Evan was attending his very first red carpet for one of his earliest feature films, the 2004 teen comedy, Sleepover. Evan played goofy teen “Russell” and, frankly, his acting was still pretty ON POINT back then, too.

I mean…

Credit: MGM

But Evan’s red carpet apparence was still totally adorable.

“Stop everything and look at me!”

“I’m not sure what face to make…”

“Does this work?!”

Awww, loving every thing about you then and now, Evan!