Sarah Terry
Updated Aug 11, 2016 @ 4:09 pm
Credit: NBC /

In the early 2000s, ALL our lockers featured magazing cutouts of our celeb crushes and of course, Andrew Keegan’s moody eyes were definitely in that bunch. He was one of our favorite dark-haired hunks, starring in some of our fave teen movies and TV series, that are still total classics.

Andrew played our favorite dreamboat, who was a little too full of himself in 10 Things I Hate About You.

He also played the teen dad Wilson on 7th Heaven, and he always made us just want to give him a hug.

He even made an appearance in this sexy leather jacket on Full House.

We found pics of Andrew now, and he’s still totally swoon-worthy.

We love that playful glint in his eye.

Credit: Paul Archuleta / Getty

And we love a man in a beanie!

Yeah, if we still had a locker, he would definitely still make it on the door.