Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.

It’s that time of year again: time to start thinking about holiday shopping. As you make your list and check it twice, we bet you’ll need a few gifts for true crime lovers. We have some suggestions that are so good, it’s scary. Best of all, every gift on this list is under $35, and most of them are less than $20.

In case you haven’t noticed, true crime is everywhere. It seems like every month, there’s a new true crime docu-series to binge and podcast to download. The genre shows no signs of slowing down, either. With Season 3 of Serial and Making a Murderer Part 2 currently streaming, the people have spoken. And they want their true crime.

Along with the rise of true crime comes the rise of true crime merch. (People want to declare their love of the genre to anyone and everyone.) So if there are any Murderinos on your holiday shopping list, look no further than these gifts for true crime lovers. Don’t be surprised if they love these gifts so much, they let out a blood-curdling scream. And if you’re a true crime doc addict or a serial killer podcast lover yourself, this is your perfect holiday wish list.

1A charm bracelet that’ll knock ‘em dead

No hearts and stars here, just murder weapons and handcuffs. You know, normal stuff for true crime junkies.

2A tote that supports their favorite podcast (and is also a big mood)

Here’s the thing: This My Favorite Murder tote is a must-have for Murderinos, a.k.a. fans of the true crime podcast.

3A wine glass that speaks to their true crime obsession

Good wine and true crime. What else does a true crime lover need in life? Bonus points if you gift the glass with a bottle of red.

4Sandwich bags that deter perps away from their lunch

Perps, co-workers, same difference.

5A doormat that speaks to what’s REALLY going on inside the house

Truer words have never been spoken. Or printed on a doormat.

6A subscription that delivers a ready-to-solve true crime case to their door

This is one of the most perfect gifts for true crime lovers ever created. Every month, they’ll get a box of clues to solve a mystery. Sign them up for one month for $30, six months for $165, or 12 months for $300.

7A mug that speaks the true crime truth

Because everyone knows the husband did it.

8A cookie cutter inspired by their favorite female serial killer

Lizzie Borden famously murdered her father and her stepmother with an axe in 1892. What better way to remember her than by baking axe-shaped cookies? Bundle this gift with red icing for full effect.

9A notebook covered with America’s most wanted

It’s a place for them to jot down case notes with the likes of Ted Bundy, the Zodiac Killer, John Wayne Gacy, and more.

10A deliciously dark candle to set the mood for a true crime binge-watch session

Wake up and smell the black vanilla.

11A T-shirt that makes their love of true crime known to all

It’s equal parts creepy and comfy.

12The classic mystery board game that lets them live their best true crime lives

We’re calling it: Ms. Scarlet with the wrench in the conservatory.

13Hair ties that could also be mistaken for murder weapons

Okay, not really. How cute are these, though?

14A pair of cozy socks that scream “Helter Skelter”

Featuring none other than Mr. Charles Manson.

15An enamel pin that gets to the heart of the matter

The hardest part is deciding between the regular one and the glittery one.