The internet can’t decide if this guy looks like Harry Potter or Zayn Malik

Accio doppelgänger! Last week, Twitter user Tallie Dar posted a couple of totally innocent selfies to his account, likely not expecting any sort of reaction. But the internet decided he looks just like Harry Potter and Zayn Malik, and — as with all things viral — people are freaking the eff out.

There’s truly nothing we love more than a good celebrity doppelgänger, but this one is particularly wild because it could be one of TWO of our favorite people (yes, we know, we know; one of them is technically fictional…but you know what we mean). And the internet is so divided right now.

Tallie posted the selfies side-by-side, captioning them “you’re a wizard harry,” a nod to his round eyeglasses and adorably nerdy good looks.

you're a wizard harry pic.twitter.com/JmHkrzAUbA

— Tallie Dar (@talliedar) August 7, 2017

But then some eagle-eyed Twitter users noticed that he actually kinda looks like Zayn. In fact, here’s a shot of Zayn for reference:

https://www.instagram.com/p/9x2M3XpqdK

Do you see it? Twitter definitely DOES. false

https://twitter.com/udfredirect/status/894692856262217729

https://twitter.com/udfredirect/status/894697220490104832

One fan was desperate to know when “Zayn” would be dropping his new album (and…same).

Zayn cut the crap when are you dropping your new album?

— Gilbert Blythe’s Security Guard (@britwillsit223) August 8, 2017

Another wanted to know if he planned on joining 1D again…LOL. false

And another simply sees both, coining him “Zayn Potter.”

Zayn Potter.

— PAMANAYAN (@rayyantlb) August 7, 2017

It seems like Tallie sees the resemblance, but he had one question for all his adoring new fans…where can he find his own Gigi Hadid?

😆🤷🏻‍♂️ wheres my gigi tho

— Tallie Dar (@talliedar) August 7, 2017

Awww! Whether you’re team Harry or team Zayn in this fight: one thing is for sure, these adorable sleepy selfies have put a spell on the internet.