Olivia Harvey
Updated August 29, 2017 7:47 am

If you’ve stepped into the realm of Riverdale and the fan theories surrounding it, you’ve probably encountered the real-life Bughead hopefuls (or perhaps are one yourself). It’s undeniable that Cole Sprouse and Lili Reinhart have some serious chemistry. Even costar Skeet Ulrich has noticed the two act “like they’ve been best friends for 20 years.” Perhaps that’s because Sprouse and Reinhart have been friends for 20 years.

Dun, dun, dun!

Sprouse posted a photo to his Instagram story that shows himself and brother, Dylan, as young Disney Channel stars posing for a photo with a girl who looks eerily like a young Lili Reinhart.

Cole Sprouse / www.instagram.com

Who is she? Could it be that Cole and Lili have known each other since childhood and that’s why their relationship is so dynamic and strong?

Or could it be that this photo symbolizes a prophecy? Perhaps Sprouse and Reinhart have met several times before in life and are therefore destined to be together forever.

Okay, before we go overboard with this, we should tell you that the girl in the photo is actually not Reinhart. Her name is Anna-Laura and she’s a college student from Texas. Anna-Laura explained that she saw the Sprouse twins while they were shooting a jet ski scene for a movie and had to snag a pic with the famous duo. false

Don’t get us wrong — we think it’s super cool that Anna-Laura appeared on Cole Sprouse’s Instagram story. Truly we do! But we would be lying if we said that weren’t a little disappointed that the Sprouse-Reinhart prophecy is just a figment of our imagination.

We’ll keep searching for signs that real-life Bughead should (and will) be real in the months to come. Stay aware, and stay informed, Riverdale fans. The truth is out there.