Sway Silently With Me on a Bed of Roses: Five Romantic Gestures That Make Me Puke Sarah Heyward

The holidays are officially over, which means the “seasonal” aisle at CVS has already been transformed into a veritable Valentine’s Day blood bath. I’m all for pink confetti nail polish and any excuse to send my loved ones heart-shaped envelopes covered in stickers, but while we’re on the topic, there are a few supposedly romantic gestures that give me a serious case of the full-body cringe. Just hearing about these heinous-yet-oh-so-common occurrences makes my heart vomit. Yes, the human heart can vomit. Here’s how:

Using My Full Name to Add Romantic Emphasis to Whatever You’re Telling Me

Not sure what I mean? It’s the simple difference between a boy saying, “I love you” (usually awesome, depending on the boy), and a boy declaring, “I love you, Sarah Heyward” (I literally get bad-chills just typing this). There’s also the in-between of “I love you, Sarah” which, to me, is still pretty terrible, but depends more on tone. My issue with this kind of full-name-declaration-of-love is that it seems to imply that whatever is being said is made more special by having my name attached to the end of it. Oh, so you weren’t talking to the squirrel outside my window or my elderly mailman. You said the name “Sarah Heyward”! By golly, that’s me! You love me! I think it’s patently ridiculous that adding someone’s name to the end of a sentence is supposed to make the sentiment any more personal. It actually feels less personal to me – like we are fulfilling some expectation taught to us by Kate Hudson movies and back issues of Cosmo. Think about the scene in American Pie when Tara Reid is about to lose her virginity but not before her boyfriend tells her, “I love you, Victoria.” This is a character we have known as VICKY throughout the movie. Suddenly she’s about to have sex so she must be called “Victoria”? So calling her by some weird formal name you’ve never used before makes your love seem more legitimate? Not a chance. This pet peeve is so pervasive in pop culture and I hate it so much that it’s gotten to the point where if my boyfriend calls me “Sarah” under any circumstance, I assume he’s really pissed at me.

Asking Me to Dance in an Unconventional Setting without Music

Another misguided attempt to be romantic for which we have to thank bad romantic comedies everywhere. You know how this goes – the guy and the girl are doing dishes in their kitchen, or standing on a mountaintop, or in the middle of a supermarket. Maybe they just had a fight or a particularly sweet moment together. The guy gives the girl a loving glance and whispers, “Dance with me.” The girl responds, “But there’s no music.” The guy presses a finger to her lips. “Just dance with me,” he says. And they dance. Wherever they are. With no music. But here is the thing! In movies, that’s exactly when they TURN THE DAMN ORCHESTRAL SCORE UP AT FULL VOLUME. So yes, we are aware that the characters supposedly aren’t hearing any music while they dance this beautiful dance together in the dog food aisle, but since we, the audience, are hearing music, it doesn’t look as weird. Well guess what, it’s weird! Have you ever tried slow dancing with no music? It’s just un-rhythmic, silent swaying, and it’s really not that fun. Once, to be funny, Chris and I tried to dance in a gazebo in the middle of a small town square in Mexico, and even doing it as a joke made me extremely uncomfortable.

Serenading Me in Public

Just don’t do it. I know, it’s a big scene in a lot of wonderful movies including Ten Things I Hate About You (RIP Heath). But in real life, it’s just embarrassing. You probably aren’t going to go to the trouble of figuring out how to get a microphone or set up the speaker system. You might break something or hurt someone when you hop up on that table in the middle of the cafeteria. Chances are, you don’t know all the words. Maybe you have a terrible singing voice. And I know for a fact there won’t be a team of high schoolers accompanying you with a choreographed dance routine. But even if you do tie up all the loose ends and plan a really amazing serenade, it’s still a serenade. In public. And I am distinctly not interested.

Leading Me Anywhere with a Trail of Rose Petals

This one isn’t actually so bad on its own. I like roses a lot and harbor some serious Flower Fairy fantasies about living in a dewy garden grove somewhere. But because the rose petal has inarguably come to symbolize Valentine’s Day, marriage proposals, and general declarations of love, I’m over it. Does any girl in the world come home to an apartment in which candles and rose petals form an arrow leading to her bedroom and NOT know exactly what is about to happen? Actually, a really funny joke would be for a boyfriend to do that and have nothing waiting on the other end. That’s the kind of rose-petal use I could get behind. But doesn’t everyone recognize this as a cliche by now? Can’t we think of some other pretty thing to jazz up our marriage proposals? Personally, I’d follow a path made out of doughnut holes and call it the best night of my life.

Asking Permission to Ask Me to Marry You

I know a ton of people will disagree with me on this one, but I had to include it. To me, asking a parent’s permission before asking your significant other to marry you falls in the bad-romantic column. Obvious exception: when said parent is seriously old-fashioned or traditional or religious or actually has expressed that he or she wishes to be asked first. But even then, I’d probably argue back. Here’s my thinking: the decision to get married should (hopefully) be something the couple has been talking about for a long time before the proposal actually takes place. In my version of things, nobody should be totally surprised by the question (I know that people often are, but that doesn’t seem like the absolute smartest way to enter a lifelong commitment). So if those weeks, months, or years of discussion are preceding this wonderful, romantic moment, why does a parent even have to factor into it? Frankly, I’m excited for the day when I get to call everyone I’m related to and tell them the amazing news. It’s a little less exciting if Mom or Dad had to give permission first. I completely get that every family has their own traditions and values, and for some couples the whole getting-married thing has to follow a strict order of events. But to me, all decisions about the future should stem from the couple itself, and on a more general note, everyone should at least think for a minute before simply perpetuating these undeniably outdated conventions. Of course, when a gigantic dowry is involved…

Now that I’ve publicly declared myself a romance grinch, let me add that I’ve gotten down and dirty with the corniest of moments. The thing about cliches like the ones I mention is that they’re common for a reason: most people love them. And I’ll admit, there are at least a few romantic tropes I’d dismissed as silly until they happened to me. If you’ve ever sheepishly found yourself cuddling while watching a sunset, you know what I mean. Let the cringe wash over you and then let it go, like a rose petal on the wind.

Image via briderose.org

comments

Please help us maintain positive conversations by refraining from posting spam, advertisements, and links to other websites or blogs. we reserve the right to remove your comment if it does not adhere to these guidelines. thanks! post a comment.

  1. Ha, I’ve had the dance one happen to me. Super awkward for everyone involved.

  2. Yeah. Pedals? No thank you. I just refuse to be lead anywhere if it isn’t with food, a la Hansel & Gretel. I mean, a train of chocolate will make me happy to follow a trail anywhere, even Hell! Probably not hell, they’d melt into a river of chocolate…or wait, that sounds good too. But it better just not be a long trail. A tummy ache is not good for anyone.

  3. I love you, Sarah Heyward, for posting this! All of what you said and more are vomit-inducing. I would die of CRINGE if my partner did any of these things. Especially the dancing. Movies always assume all couples have rhythm. Dancing is just the worst.

  4. The rose petals thing was ruined for me by Buffy. Now I just expect DEATH AND DESTRUCTION EVERYWHERE.

    Also, it’s tacky, but mainly the death.

  5. That last one is, historically, distinctly unromantic. Back in the day, daughters were considered the property of their fathers, and suitors would have to ask the dad in order for ownership of the daughter to pass over to the new husband. Women were like commodities, so it was almost a business thing. Sexy.

    My husband asked me over dinner, after we had already been talking about it, after we’d already found out I was pregnant, and he put on a kind of weird face, like he was trying to be romantic about it. I was like “yeah sure” :P

  6. Oh man, I’ve had the first 3 happen to me, but I think the most cringe-worthy one was the “I love you” with the full name. And by full name I mean first, middle & last. I was so weirded out that he received a “thank you” from me in response. :)

  7. Okay, as soon as I read the headline “Serenading Me in Public” I thought “Top Gun”– am I too old for this ride? ;-) Fun article!

  8. The name thing!!! omg the name thing… Any time my husband says “melody” or “mel” when he’s talking to me, I honestly think he’s mad at me. He only ever calls me “melmel” or those other pet names like “love” or “doll” or whatever… which I’m totally fine with. As soon as he says my name I feel like a scolded dog.

  9. Totally agree with you on the full name and the asking permission thing! My full name is Alexandra but I ALWAYS go by Alex (not even my family calls me Alexandra), so it actually sets me on edge to hear my full name. It’s like when a stranger uses it because they don’t know me at ALL…not even the ten seconds’ worth of information to know that I go by Alex and have since I was a baby.

    And the last one is so obnoxious. My parents *are* the traditional/religious type, but when I finally do decide to get married, this will be something that we disagree on, because I think the entire concept is completely archaic and ridiculous. We’re not factoring how many goats I’m worth anymore, and the last time I asked my parents’ permission for something, I believe I was under the legal voting age.

    A trail of donut holes…omg that would be the perfect man…

  10. I totally agree on the rose petals, and a few months ago I even warned my hubby about that. Mainly because as you said, it IS just ridiculous and secondly, because take a wild guess who would have to be unromantically cleaning it up afterwards! lol! Now, I’m afraid my Dad is COMPLETELY old-fashioned and I warned my then boyfriend (now husband) of that and although it wasn’t his style at all to put up with that, he did, which made me love him all the more. He wanted to surprise me with the proposal, but one night when we were visiting my folks I had a funny feeling he was going to approach my Dad so I made myself “conveniently” disappear to talk to Mom and Grandma in the other room and sure enough, they closed the door in the sun room and started chatting. (How cute, trying to be sneaky!) Mom, Grandma and I were just hiding away, giggling the whole time! Have to admit, I’m unabashedly a romantic, so I think that is just too darn cute. :-)

  11. I’d like to add another draw back to the rose-petal path… S/he better be planning to clean that up, because I’m not doing it!

  12. I totally agree with that last one, but for me it comes from living in the south and hearing every girl I know say they wouldn’t say yes unless he asked their dad first. What does your dad have to do with anything? My ex asked my dad for permission (after I told him not to)… that engagement didn’t last very long. Thanks for a great post, Sarah!

HelloGiggles Podcast