Obsession and Sherlock Holmes: Why The Two Go Hand In Hand

As you read this, filming on the third series of the BBC’s runaway success, Sherlock, has begun. Cameras are rolling. Lights are set. Continuity errors have been checked. Costumes, makeup and hair will be primed. Martin Freeman has already inspired a thousand .gif sets on tumblr. The entire fandom will collapse blissfully into hysterics. Cue the impending breakdown in 3…2…1….

As we down a cup of chamomile to calm our anxious nerves (Was Mycroft involved? What will happen to John? WHERE IS MRS. HUDSON?), it helps to know that this isn’t the first time a fan base has gone haywire over a momentous occasion in the Consulting Detective’s life. In 1893, author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle had grown weary of writing a character whom he considered to be a taxing and wholly irritating, one that overshadowed some of his other considerably varied works. The burden of publishing a continual weekly series in The Strand had become too much. What is a writer to do, then, when they’ve tired of a story? Why, kill off the main character and close the book, since you ask.

So, Conan Doyle did just that.


Sherlock Holmes “The Final Problem”, circa 1893

Unfortunately, this did not sit well with followers of the series. To say that fans of the great fictional detective were unimpressed would be to say that the Titanic collided with a few ice cubes, had a tussle and then moved on. What actually transpired was something more akin to a nuclear bomb being detonated in a factory full of Sour Patch Kids coated in motor oil and the souls of all the “angry men” they sang about in Les Misérables. Conan Doyle had been frustrated over fans’ letters requesting that the great detective help them solve their personal problems, but now he was receiving post of a different sort. Hate mail and threats poured in by the bundle. He was scandalized in the papers and treated contemptuously in public. After 10 years of public urgings and several unsuccessful attempts to bring attention to his unrecognized historical novels, Conan Doyle gave in and, in 1903, published the first in a series of 13 stories, entitled The Return of Sherlock Holmes.

As we all know, Sherlock Holmes went on to become one of the most celebrated and widely read fictional characters of all time and Conan Doyle cemented his place in the world of literary royalty. Still, it begs the question: what is it about Holmes that fans love so single-mindedly?

Could it be the detective’s sharp wits? His aversion to the public through any means necessary? His friendship with Dr. Watson? Do we love the man or his methods?

Part of the answer lies simply in the way the stories were written: Conan Doyle himself was considered such a unique mind that he was solicited by Scotland Yard to consult in public court cases, which he accomplished to great acclaim, partially leading to the establishment of The Court of Criminal Appeal in 1907. Conan Doyle’s Holmes novels were no different; the methodology employed by Sherlock and Watson to unravel the most curious of cases is, to this day, so astounding that many are still puzzled by the trail of clues in each of the stories. Conan Doyle never wrote crass or tasteless plotlines that were jumbled by the time you found the other end of the yarn. Instead, his tales were interwoven and tactfully orchestrated to yield only the most intricately simple results possible, conclusions that still lead us to shout, “How did I not notice that?!”

The second half of Sherlock Holmes’ success lies with the detective himself: the character of Sherlock lends itself to so many interpretations, while still maintaining that innate “Holmesian” quality that we all fiercely love. Brainy, sociopathic, drug addicted, deep thinking and gentlemanly in the most perplexing of ways, Sherlock Holmes is every actor’s dream project. In the aforementioned BBC production of the same name, Sherlock (played exquisitely by Benedict Cumberbatch) is a modern day incarnation of the great detective who comes off as a case-laden, tech-savvy, quick-witted and staggeringly genius-level “high-functioning sociopath”. Many believe that this was the Sherlock Holmes Conan Doyle had pictured while piecing together his numberless stories. Still others see him as Elementary’s eccentric Jonny Lee Miller, a veteran actor whose contemporary take on Holmes is more along the lines of a pragmatic, logic-ridden former addict who employs his free time occupying the NYPD’s crime scenes and evidence lockers.

CBS Elementary

Jonny Lee Miller as Sherlock in the CBS drama Elementary

The massively talented Miller gives fans a rare glimpse into the softer side of the astute puzzle-solver while the character unknowingly bolsters his own self-confidence through instructing fellow colleague and protégé, Dr. Joan Watson.

1 2Continue reading
  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1706393732 Letícia Magalhães

    I watch BBC’s Sherlock and Elementary. But I can’t totally see the second as Sherlock Holmes. So far, my favorite is Cumberbatch’s incarnation, but I intend to watch The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and see if everybody is right when say Jeremy Brett is awesome in it.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=17801143 Melanie Schmitz

      Me too– I’m a HUGE Cumberbabe.


      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=16109010 Amanda Alguire Vredenburgh

        Also known as “Cumberbitches” :)

        • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=17801143 Melanie Schmitz

          Oh yes. :)

          I started using “Cumberbabes” since he told an interviewer that he liked “Cumberbitches” but thought it “might be a bit derogatory” and that he’d “prefer something a little nicer like ‘Cumberbabes’,”…. I thought, “Well hell, I’ll be whatever you want, sir. ANYTHING. ANYTHING AT ALL.”

          The CumberKing.

          • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=16109010 Amanda Alguire Vredenburgh

            I missed that. I guess I’m all “Cumberbabes” now too!

            • http://idontlikeyourcat.tumblr.com/ Melanie Schmitz


              That man could sell ice to an eskimo with that scrumptious voice of his. :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=594951508 Melly Parrwood

    Benedict is the ultimate Sherlock for me , he’s enigmatic and mysteriously sexy!!!!! However i love Jeremy Brett’s incarnation as he is so quintisentially english in his approach with an air of dangerous arrogance!!!! Conan Doyle created one of the most complicated characters in murder/mystery fiction!!!! Must be a real tester to an actor!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=530738621 Maeby Hyland

    Totally team BBC Sherlock, Elementary seems too ‘American’ (I know its supposed to be in NY) but it loses a lot of the magic transporting it. In ACD’s books London is as much a vital element to setting the tone of the stories as the detectives themselves. Also honorable mention to “Young Sherlock Holmes’ just watched it and its so cheesy its good.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=46901672 Lauren Nicole

    Cumberbatch Sherlock is the BEST!. And Freeman as Watson? Ugh I love it. I got 3 of my other friends hooked and made them watch the Reichenbach Fall with me just so I could watch their reactions. Steven Moffat is a brilliant writer.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=637162602 Carrie Ann

    OMG I just watched BBC’s Sherlock for the first time last month, marathoning it all over an embarrassingly short period of time, of course. And I fell totally head over heels for it, only to be devastated by that ending!! But now you’re telling me a 3rd season is coming out?! YES YES, THANK YOU YES <3

    On the other Sherlocks, though, I've only seen the RDJ movie and, while it was really awesome and I loved it, BBC takes the cake for me <3 Mr. Cumberbatch is fabulously addictive, and Martin Freeman is, as always, irresistibly lovable.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=16109010 Amanda Alguire Vredenburgh

    I just watched both series (in 3 days) of BBC Sherlock in January. And now I am OBSESSED with it as well as with Benedict Cumberbatch (or, “Benny”, as I affectionatley call him when I talk to my poor husband about Sherlock). I spent HOURS online trying to find out the “missing clue” that is supposed to tell us how Sherlock survived. I CANNOT WAIT for Series 3.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1198014294 Steve Gengler

    Wow what a great article. Melanie , I am very impressed and love your style. Your bio is hilarious Now you have a new number one fan. Not the crazy I’m going to spy on you when you are closing the salon late at night all by yourself every night from now on or any thing. Just your run of the mill number one fan.I knew you super cool ever since the first time you completely ignored me. Nice work.

    Steve G.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=17801143 Melanie Schmitz

      Oh geez– ahahaha

      Thanks, Steve!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1550760777 Colleen Abel

    I used to watch Sherlock on Masterpiece Mystery with my dad growing up so my heart belong to Jeremy Brett (and Edward Gorey). Cumberbatch and Lee are both doing astounding jobs in their series, though. I have a few theories about the fall but am positively dying to know what really happened! So incredibly relieved to know that the waiting will be over shortly :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100005041987694 Mary Elizabeth Chupp

    Another brilliant article!

Need more Giggles?
Like us on Facebook!