You're not going to like this, but coconut oil is just as bad for you as butter

Getty Images/RUSS ROHDE

Hemp milk, collagen peptides, kombucha, agave, ghee, matcha, spirulina…

If you’ve spent any time on Instagram lately, these names will probably sound familiar (even if you might not have any clue what some of them actually mean). These days, good-for-you ingredients are all the rage, and the onslaught of new ones can seem never-ending. With a new fad popping up every day, most of us are inclined to stop paying attention at some point and stick to our basic, go-to health foods.

Related article: American Academy of Pediatrics says no juice for babies

But there’s one ingredient you probably wouldn’t expect to see fall off the holistic health bandwagon, and that’s coconut oil. After all, it’s been the darling of wellness fanatics for quite some time now, appearing all over blogs, Pinterest and healthy-eating cookbooks. Its benefits have been touted by celebrities. At this point, it’s practically canonized in Healthy Eating 101.

But the oil may not be all that it’s been cracked up to be. Scratch that: Coconut oil, it seems, might not just be “not good for you”; it might be straight-up bad for you.

Related article: Science says you can rub wasabi on your head to stimulate hair growth

At least, that’s what the American Heart Association is warning us. In their recently-updated fat guidelines, the organization urges Americans to remove the fatty oil from their diets, explaining that coconut oil is extremely high in saturated fats. The Association makes it clear that while it’s true that the majority of saturated fats in our diet come from animal products and byproducts, plant-based products, including coconut oil and palm oil, contain them, too. The AHA lists coconut oil right alongside other culprits high in saturated fat, including beef and butter, all of which can raise levels of “bad” cholesterol and further the risk of Type 2 diabetes.

Related article: Bacon camp is very real and you can go this summer

What’s more, just one tablespoon of coconut oil has 12 grams of saturated fat, while one tablespoon of olive oil contains only one gram. If you’re thinking of switching over (or back) to olive oil, we can help you out: Get our 9 ultimate tips for buying and using the stuff, then get cooking with our favorite olive oil recipes.

This article originally appeared in Foodandwine.com

newsletter illustration

Giggles in Your Inbox

!